Women's Hockey 101 (with Cassie from Raw Charge)
Written by James O'Brien   
Tuesday, 23 February 2010 17:28

cammigranato

Big thanks to friend of the blog Cassie from SBN's Raw Charge for providing this introduction to Women's Hockey. Make sure to check out Raw Charge and follow Cassie on Twitter.

 

There has been a lot of discussion about women’s ice hockey lately. The United States will meet Canada to play for the gold medal – again – on Thursday, and it was pretty much a foregone conclusion that they’d be playing each other for the gold from the beginning. For both teams, their opponents appeared to be nothing more than speed bumps on the way to this game.

Scores like 18-0, 13-0, 12-1 were common for those two national teams, and many people have been questioning whether women’s ice hockey should be an Olympic event because of the lack of suitable competition. So let me explain women’s hockey. I used to play, so I know how this goes.

First off, there’s a very good reason why the US and Canada have easily out-played their competition. Canada has had a women’s hockey program in place since at least the 1980s. The US has had a women’s hockey program for probably about as long and both countries have had girls playing on boys teams for a lot longer than that.

The very first international women’s hockey tournament was held in 1990. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) decided in 1992 to make women’s ice hockey a gold medal event at the 1998 Olympics in Nagano, Japan. Only six countries participated in that first Olympics for the sport in 1998: The US (gold), Canada (silver), Finland (bronze), China, Sweden, and the host country, Japan. So women’s hockey is a relatively young sport.

sisters

Smile like the Lamoureuxs

The real problem with women’s hockey is that the women’s programs for most of the other participating nations are at least a good 10 years behind the US and Canada. I would guess that most countries got their programs going right after the IOC’s announcement in 1992. Sweden and Finland, despite being blown out by the US and Canada in this Olympics, have become pretty competitive. The rest of the field is still catching up, however. Give it another ten years and you’ll probably see the level of international competition jump up significantly.

Women’s hockey is different than the men’s. There’s no getting around that. The rules are pretty much the same with two significant exceptions.

The first is that women’s hockey players are required to wear full face protection. Most wear metal wire cages, but some wear the clear plastic shields. It used to be that neck guards were required as well, but I believe that’s optional at the senior level now.

The biggest difference between men’s and women’s hockey is that body checking is a penalty for the women. Now don’t get that wrong – the woman’s game is still very physical. But lining someone up and checking them into the boards and open ice hits are penalties.

Women do know how to body check and they would very much like to be able to. But at this time, it’s against the rules. The reason for it, from what I was told when I played, is that a woman could get a stick end in the lower abdomen and be injured so that she may not be able to have children because of that. The same thing goes with the men, of course, but it’s the women that actually have the babies – that’s the difference. There is additional padding that is required for women to wear to cover their lower abdomens, but that apparently doesn’t make any difference to the rule makers.

baby

Babies are to blame for, like, everything really.

See, this is what happens when old men make the rules for a women’s sport, and it drives us women nuts. We’d very much like to play hockey as the men do, and we all consider that to be “real” hockey, but we’re not allowed simply because we are able to bear children.

Sadly, hockey isn’t the only sport infected with this wrong-headed kind of thinking.

The reason that women know how to body check is because women’s teams play boys teams when there aren’t any other women’s teams around. While in women’s hockey checking isn’t allowed, in mixed games it is – or it can be. Women’s teams will play high school aged boys teams for competition. Before the game, each team will vote on whether to include checking or not. Then the coaches and officials meet, and they give the team’s decisions. And checking is almost always allowed. Women will take any chance they can to play “real” hockey, and teenage boys won’t pass up the opportunity to body check women if it’s legal.

In the younger age brackets, girls will play on the same teams as boys. And, if there aren’t enough girls to form a team in an area, then they’ll make allowances to girls to play with the boys into the teen years. Very occasionally, a girl will play with high school aged boys, especially if she’s good enough. As the girl gets older, however, the ones that are able to play with the boys the longest are the goaltenders.

manon

Manon Rheaume, the only woman to ever play in the NHL (albeit briefly)

Girls who play as defensemen and forwards aren’t usually able to keep up with the boys after a while. And there’s a good read for that: it’s called biology. It has nothing to do with height and weight – though that does become a consideration for many – so much as speed.

The women’s game is a little slower than the men’s game. It’s about on pace with high school boys hockey, so it’s not as if it’s really slow. Most of the women who play in the Olympics for the US are college hockey players, and female collegiate athletes are typically very good and pretty fast.

The speed problem comes from physiology. Men’s legs are right underneath them; their knees usually line up with their hip sockets when they stand with their feet shoulder’s width apart. So their thighbones go from hip to knee in a fairly straight line, and that gives them a very efficient skating stride.

Women, because we bear children, aren’t built like that. When we stand with our feet shoulder’s length apart, our knees line up inside our hip sockets. Our thigh bones come into our knees at an angle – not straight above like the men’s thighbones do. This is why women have far more knee problems than men do, as a general rule, but it also makes our skating strides less efficient and therefore makes us not as quick as the men.

It really is the same sport, however, despite its differences. And, in actuality, the differences aren’t that great. Some people enjoy the women’s game more because there isn’t any checking, because that’s seen as creating a better flow to the game. But until there is more competition for the US and Canada – and there will be, you just have to be patient – these blowouts are just not entertaining.

However, before you make any judgment about women’s ice hockey, watch the gold medal game between the US and Canada on Thursday. That will be as competitive and as physical game as you could possibly ask for. And, you might be surprised by how much you like it.

 

 

About Bloguin

Bloguin is the revolutionary blog network specifically focused on helping bloggers get the most out of their websites. We're currently working on building a large network of online communities and hope to expand our blogging coverage to include a wide range of topics.

Advertisers

The Bloguin Network allows advertisers to promote their products and services to our ever-growing number of visitors. We offer both site-specific ad placements as well as the ability to run a network-wide campaign. If you're interested in working with Bloguin to meet your advertising needs, please contact us.

Bloggers Wanted

The Bloguin Network is always looking to expand. We're specifically looking for blogs in the sports, entertainment, and video games field, but are open to adding any type of quality site. If you're a blogger and interested in joining our network, please fill out our application form.

The Bloguin Login

The Bloguin Login gives you full access to everything our network has to offer. Your name and password will work for each and every one of our sites. Signing up is simple, and will allow you to post in all our forums, create member blogs, and access other cool features! What are you waiting for? Create an Account!